Ice dams after adding insulation in my Ottawa attic, why?
Ice dams after adding insulation in my Ottawa attic, why?
Adding insulation does not stop ice dams on its own if warm air still reaches the attic. Here is how to think it through.
Why More Insulation Can Make Ice Dams Worse
Natural Resources Canada explains that when the attic is above freezing, it warms the roof sheathing and melts the snow in contact with the roof; the water runs down and freezes at the edge as an ice dam. Insulation alone does not stop warm air leaking from the house into the attic.
Natural Resources Canada's guidance on this is clear: a well-sealed and insulated attic produces a cool roof and generally will not have ice dams. So ask whether air sealing was part of the insulation job.
Ventilation is the other piece. The 2024 Ontario Building Code (Div. B, 9.19.1.2.) requires a vent area of not less than 1/300 of the insulated ceiling area, with at least 25 per cent of the openings at the top of the attic space and at least 25 per cent at the bottom. The Code also requires at least 63 mm of clear space between the insulation and the roof sheathing in vented roof-joist spaces, and baffles must leave at least 25 mm of air space (9.19.1.3.). If the new insulation was blown or batted in without baffles at the eaves, it may have blocked the soffit vents entirely. The Code says ceiling insulation must not restrict the free flow of air through roof vents (9.19.1.3.), and NRCan notes that ventilation keeps the attic colder and less prone to ice dams.
NRCan also notes that complicated roofs with many valleys, dormers or large overhangs are more prone to ice damming.
From inside the attic, look for frost on the sheathing on a cold morning, damp or compressed insulation near the eaves, and whether you can see daylight through the soffit baffles. If the baffles are buried or missing, that is worth fixing before next winter. The 2024 Ontario Building Code (Div. B, 9.26.5.1.) requires eave protection on shingle roofs, running at least 900 mm up the roof slope to a line at least 300 mm inside the inner face of the exterior wall. That membrane limits water pushed back by an ice dam from entering the building, but it does not stop the dam from forming.
A fix can combine air sealing, baffles that are in place and unobstructed, and ridge and soffit vents that meet the Code's vent area. Ask the roofer for the vent area calculation in writing.
When you have two written quotes in front of you for this work, put the ventilation scope, the baffle specification, the eave protection detail and the disposal plan side by side line by line before deciding which to accept.
Related service: Roof Ventilation and Ice Dams
Want this done at your place?
Tell us about your roof and we'll send it to local Ottawa roofing contractors, who reply by email. We send it out to local contractors for you. Free, no pressure.
Roofing IQ -- Built from the Ontario Building Code, Ontario regulations and City of Ottawa sources and real construction experience. Answers are for informational purposes only and are not a professional assessment.
Ready to Get Quotes?
Find local roofing contractors in Ottawa. Free matching, no obligation.