Near the top of the published range for a Barrhaven two-storey roof: fair quote?
Near the top of the published range for a Barrhaven two-storey roof: fair quote?
Published Ottawa-area quotes for asphalt shingle replacement with a one-layer tear-off run about $8,000 to $22,000, so a quote near the top of that range is not automatically unfair, but it does need to be explained line by line before you sign anything.
Several things show up in a quote at the higher end of that range: the roof's size and pitch, access, and complexity: valleys, dormers, a chimney, or multiple roof planes each add labour and flashing work. If the roofer has flagged any of these on your roof, the higher number may reflect the actual scope. What you want to confirm is whether the quote spells out each of those items or whether it is a single lump sum with no breakdown.
The 2024 Ontario Building Code (Div. B, 9.26.5.1.) requires eave protection running at least 900 mm up the roof slope to a line not less than 300 mm inside the inner face of the exterior wall. It must be installed when shingles are replaced. The Code also requires valleys to be flashed (9.26.4.3.), and a chimney saddle where the upper side of a chimney on a sloping roof is more than 750 mm wide (9.26.4.8.). A fair quote names these items; a quote that omits them is not a complete picture of the job. The City of Ottawa's list of projects not requiring a building permit names installing asphalt shingles, though the Code still applies. If your home is designated or in a Heritage Conservation District, talk to the City's heritage planners before work starts.
On the business side, the Consumer Protection Act, 2002 requires that a direct agreement, which a quote signed at your kitchen table is likely to be, set out a fair description of the work, the total amount payable, the terms of payment, and an itemized list of prices including taxes. You have 10 days to cancel after receiving that written copy. If the quote includes an estimate, the supplier cannot charge more than 10 per cent above it. The Construction Act requires you to hold back 10 per cent of the price of services and materials as they are supplied; ask a lawyer about release timing. Ask the roofer for their WSIB clearance before work starts; the homeowner exemption covers the home you live in, not a rental or investment property.
Sheathing found to be rotten at tear-off is priced as an extra; published Ottawa-area quotes show about $3 to $6 per square foot of sheathing replaced. Ask whether that rate is already written into the quote or whether it will appear as a surprise charge.
When you set two written quotes side by side, line up the tear-off scope and number of layers, the eave protection specification, the flashing and valley details, the ventilation work if any, the sheathing rate per square foot, and what each contractor does with the old material, so you are comparing the same job rather than two different scopes of work.
What it costs: Shingle roof replacement
Want this done at your place?
Tell us about your roof and we'll send it to local Ottawa roofing contractors, who reply by email. We send it out to local contractors for you. Free, no pressure.
Roofing IQ -- Built from the Ontario Building Code, Ontario regulations and City of Ottawa sources and real construction experience. Answers are for informational purposes only and are not a professional assessment.
Ready to Get Quotes?
Find local roofing contractors in Ottawa. Free matching, no obligation.