Free Roofer Matching Repairs, Re-Roofing, Flat & Metal Roofs Roofing Across Ottawa
Find a Roofer
Costs & Pricing | 0 views |

Should I pick metal or asphalt on price alone for my Ottawa home?

Question

Should I pick metal or asphalt on price alone for my Ottawa home?

Answer from Roofing IQ

Choosing on price alone is harder than it looks, because the two materials are priced in different units. Published Ottawa-area quotes put asphalt shingle replacement at about $8,000 to $22,000 for a typical house with one layer torn off. Metal roofing runs about $8 to $22 per square foot installed, with standing seam at the upper end of that range. Because metal is quoted per square foot, only a full written quote for your roof shows how the two totals compare.

Several things shift the comparison before you even get to material preference. Roof size, pitch, and complexity, including valleys, dormers, and chimneys, show up in both quotes. Tear-off adds cost on either side: if there is more than one existing layer, that work is priced separately and we found too few published Ottawa figures to quote it. Rotten sheathing found at tear-off runs about $3 to $6 per square foot as an extra on either job. Flashing, ventilation upgrades, and disposal are also separate line items that can move the final number.

The permit question matters here

The City of Ottawa lists installing asphalt shingles as a project that does not need a building permit, though heritage-designated properties are not exempt. For metal roofing, we found no City of Ottawa statement confirming an exemption, so confirm with the City before work starts. Either way, the 2024 Ontario Building Code applies. For metal, the Code sets a minimum slope of 1 in 4 for profiled metal roofing, with lower slopes allowed for low-slope profiled metal systems installed to the manufacturer's written recommendations (Div. B, 9.26.3.1.). When shingles are replaced, the eave protection rule applies: protection must run at least 900 mm up the roof slope to a line at least 300 mm inside the inner face of the exterior wall (Div. B, 9.26.5.1.). Ottawa's heating degree-days of roughly 4,440 to 4,520 mean the climate exemption does not apply here.

On lifespan, a 2007 NAHB industry study puts asphalt shingles at about 20 years; for metal, only roofers and manufacturers publish figures, so read the written warranty carefully. The NAHB notes that local weather, installation quality, and maintenance all affect how long any roof lasts.

A fair quote for either material should spell out, in writing: roof area and pitch, number of layers being removed, sheathing replacement price per square foot, eave protection, flashing, ventilation work, and disposal. Ask whether the contractor carries WSIB coverage; as a homeowner hiring for your own residence you are not required to obtain a clearance, but you can search the contractor's current clearance online. Under the Consumer Protection Act, 2002, if you sign a quote at your home rather than the contractor's office, you have 10 days to cancel without reason.

Ask each roofer to show you exactly how sheathing replacement, extra layers, and disposal are priced, since those lines can add to the final invoice.

Ottawa Roofing Pro

Want this done at your place?

Tell us about your roof and we'll send it to local Ottawa roofing contractors, who reply by email. We send it out to local contractors for you. Free, no pressure.

Fields marked are required.

We won't call you. There's no phone box above because we don't ask for one — your estimate comes by email, on your time.

Request received We’ve sent your details to local Ottawa roofing contractors. Interested roofers reply by email. A confirmation is on its way to your inbox.

Roofing IQ -- Built from the Ontario Building Code, Ontario regulations and City of Ottawa sources and real construction experience. Answers are for informational purposes only and are not a professional assessment.

Ready to Get Quotes?

Find local roofing contractors in Ottawa. Free matching, no obligation.

Find a Roofer