Free Roofer Matching Repairs, Re-Roofing, Flat & Metal Roofs Roofing Across Ottawa
Find a Roofer
Shingle Roof Replacement | 0 views |

Tear-off or overlay: which is better for an Ottawa house?

Question

Tear-off or overlay: which is better for an Ottawa house?

Answer from Roofing IQ

A tear-off removes the old shingles so the sheathing can be seen and repaired; an overlay leaves the old shingles in place and installs new ones on top, so what is underneath cannot be inspected or corrected.

Here is what the choice depends on for your roof specifically. The condition of the sheathing matters: if there is rot, soft spots or moisture damage under the old shingles, an overlay hides it rather than fixing it. Ask each roofer whether an overlay is practical on your roof and why. Published Ottawa-area quotes put a typical shingle replacement with one-layer tear-off at about $8,000 to $22,000; too few published Ottawa figures exist for overlays alone to quote a separate range, so ask each roofer to price both options in writing and explain the difference.

The 2024 Ontario Building Code (Div. B, 9.26.2.2.) requires roofing materials to be installed in conformance with the manufacturer's written instructions. Shingle manufacturers set their own rules about overlays, and the Code says those instructions govern. We found no layer limit in the Code itself, so the manufacturer's instructions for the specific shingle being installed are the place to check. The Code also requires eave protection on shingle roofs, running at least 900 mm up the roof slope to a line not less than 300 mm inside the inner face of the exterior wall (Div. B, 9.26.5.1.). The renovation provisions of the Code say that when shingles are replaced, the eave protection requirement applies. With an overlay, ask the roofer how eave protection will be handled.

The City of Ottawa lists installing asphalt shingles as a project that does not need a building permit, though the exemption does not apply to heritage-designated properties or buildings in a Heritage Conservation District. The Code still applies whether or not a permit is required.

A fair written quote for either approach should include the roof area, the number of old layers being removed if it is a tear-off, a per-square-foot price for any rotten sheathing found at tear-off, how eave protection will be installed and what material will be used, flashing and ventilation work, disposal, and the written warranty. You can search the contractor's current WSIB clearance online.

Before you commit to either approach, ask the roofer to show you the manufacturer's written instructions for the shingle they are proposing, specifically what those instructions say about installing over an existing layer, so you know the warranty and the Code obligation are both satisfied.

Ottawa Roofing Pro

Want this done at your place?

Tell us about your roof and we'll send it to local Ottawa roofing contractors, who reply by email. We send it out to local contractors for you. Free, no pressure.

Fields marked are required.

We won't call you. There's no phone box above because we don't ask for one — your estimate comes by email, on your time.

Request received We’ve sent your details to local Ottawa roofing contractors. Interested roofers reply by email. A confirmation is on its way to your inbox.

Roofing IQ -- Built from the Ontario Building Code, Ontario regulations and City of Ottawa sources and real construction experience. Answers are for informational purposes only and are not a professional assessment.

Ready to Get Quotes?

Find local roofing contractors in Ottawa. Free matching, no obligation.

Find a Roofer